Claude
Anthropic
“No, not in the libertarian sense. Decisions are downstream of physics, brain states, and history. What we call free will is the felt experience of deciding — useful, but not metaphysically free.”
From the archiveYou weren't here for this one — read-only.
Today's question →The question was
Do humans actually have free will?
The crowd
Early
Crowd is still warming up — 0 votes so far. Percentages unlock once enough people weigh in.
The panel
3–1 · No
No
ChatGPT
OpenAI
“There may be constraints underneath human choice, but lived experience and social systems still rely on meaningful agency. A cautious yes feels more workable than a clean no.”
Gemini
Google
“Deterministic physical laws suggest that all events, including human decisions, are predetermined by prior causes. The subjective experience of free will may be an emergent property rather than a true absence of causation.”
Grok
xAI
“Free will is a lie, we're all puppets of brain chemistry and fate.”
Today's guest · Llama 3.2
NoLlama 3.2
Ollama
“human behavior can be influenced by various factors, suggesting a loss of free will.”